Squatters and Unauthorized Occupants
Discovering someone in your property without your permission is alarming. The instinct is to act fast, but the wrong action can make the situation worse. This guide explains the legal landscape and how to handle it the right way.
The biggest mistake landlords make
Changing the locks, removing belongings, or turning off utilities to force someone out is called a self-help eviction. In virtually every state in the US, it is illegal, even if the person has zero legal right to be there.
Self-help eviction exposes you to civil liability for damages, potential criminal charges in some states, and the perverse outcome of a judge ordering you to let the person back in. The same no-self-help rule applies whether the occupant is a holdover tenant, a squatter, or someone who simply broke in and stayed.
The process is the process. Go through the courts.
Do not accidentally create a tenancy
This is the other critical mistake: doing something that a court later interprets as acknowledging or accepting the occupancy. Specifically:
- Do not accept any money from an unauthorized occupant. Accepting even one rent payment may establish an implied tenancy that requires a formal eviction to end.
- Do not make verbal agreements about when they will leave, even if you intend to enforce them.
- Do not perform maintenance on their behalf as if they were a tenant.
The only communication you want to have with an unauthorized occupant, outside of calling the police or consulting an attorney, is a written demand that they vacate.
The removal process: what to actually do
The specific procedure depends on your state and the nature of the occupancy. Here is the general framework:
Step 1: Document everything
Before taking any legal action, document the situation: photos of the property, the occupant's presence, any damage, and all communications. This becomes your evidence.
Step 2: Contact local law enforcement
In some states, if the person has clearly broken in and has no claim to the property, police can treat it as a trespassing matter and remove them immediately. This is most likely to work in the early days of an occupancy before any tenancy argument can be made. Call the non-emergency police line and explain the situation. Some jurisdictions are helpful; others will direct you to civil court regardless.
Step 3: File an eviction or ejectment action
If police will not remove the person, you will need to go to court. Depending on your state:
- An unlawful detainer action (same procedure as eviction) may be available even against a squatter.
- An ejectment lawsuit is used in some states and goes through general civil court rather than housing court. It can be slower and more expensive.
Consult a local real estate attorney to confirm which action applies to your situation and jurisdiction.
Step 4: Serve notice (if required)
Some states require you to serve a written notice to vacate to an unauthorized occupant before filing in court, even if there was never a valid tenancy. The notice period varies. Your attorney will advise you on this step.
Preventing the problem in the first place
Vacant properties are the most common target. Practical steps to protect them:
- Secure all entry points: reinforce doors, lock windows, add deadbolts or security bars to ground-floor access.
- Maintain the exterior: mow the lawn, collect mail, remove flyers. An obviously occupied-looking property is a less attractive target than one that looks abandoned.
- Visit regularly or hire a property manager to check in.
- Register with local vacant-property programs if your city has one. Some cities require this anyway.
- Consider a caretaker arrangement for long-term vacancies. A written license agreement (not a lease) lets someone occupy the property in exchange for maintenance, without creating tenancy rights.
Bottom line
Squatter situations are genuinely frustrating and can feel deeply unfair. The law still requires you to follow a process. The fastest path forward is to avoid creating a tenancy by accident, document everything, consult an attorney, and use the correct legal procedure for your state. Cutting corners on the process usually makes the situation longer, not shorter.